fidelius vs Infisical: an Infisical alternative

If you want an open-source platform you can host for a team, CI and production, or a proxy that gives agents placeholder credentials, Infisical. If you want your own development keys on your Macs with nothing to host or sign in to, fidelius.

We make fidelius. Infisical facts come from its docs, pricing page and GitHub, checked on October 4, 2026.

How each one works

Infisical stores secrets in Infisical Cloud or on a server you run, with projects, environments and access controls. The CLI injects them into a command and caches them for offline use:

$ infisical run --env=dev -- npm run dev

fidelius stores keys in your iCloud Keychain, grouped by project in a Mac app, and accio injects them:

$ accio myapp npm run dev

Side by side

Infisicalfidelius
PriceFree: 5 identities, unlimited projects. Pro $20/identity/mo annual, $23 monthlyFree for the shared project; Pro $24 once
HostingInfisical Cloud or self-hostedNothing to host; iCloud Keychain
AccountInfisical login or machine identityNone
OfflineCLI uses cached secretsYes, keys are on the Mac
PlatformsmacOS, Linux, Windows, CI, serversmacOS 15 or later
Output masking in the CLINot found for infisical run; opt-in masking in the MCP serverWhen Claude Code or Codex runs it, or with FIDELIUS_MASK=1
AI agentsMCP server, Agent Proxy that swaps placeholder keys for real onesWrites instructions into Claude Code, Codex and Gemini CLI
Team featuresYes: access controls, rotation, SSO and audit logs on ProNo
Open sourceYes, MIT outside its ee/ folderNo

Where Infisical is the better choice

  • You want to own the server. Self-host the MIT core and keep secrets on infrastructure you control.
  • Teams, CI and production. One source for laptops, pipelines and servers.
  • Placeholder credentials for agents. For requests routed through Agent Proxy, the agent holds a placeholder and the proxy swaps in the real credential on the way out. That's a stronger boundary than masking, as long as the agent doesn't also get CLI or MCP access to the values. Static secrets work on the free plan.

Where fidelius is the better choice

  • Nothing to run. No server, no cloud account, no machine identities. Install the app and add keys.
  • Sync between your Macs is built in, through iCloud Keychain with Apple's end-to-end encryption.
  • One price, once. $24 for every project, against per-identity pricing once you outgrow the free plan.
  • Agents set up in one step for Claude Code, Codex and Gemini CLI.

Using both

Infisical for shared and deployed secrets, fidelius for keys only you use while developing on your Macs. To move a project's development keys, export them once with infisical export --format=dotenv --output-file=.env, run accio import, then delete the file.